Skip to content
  • Essence GU
  • Beautycon
  • NaturallyCurly
  • Afropunk
  • Essence Studios
  • Soko Mrkt
  • Ese Funds
  • Refinery29
Sign In
  • 2025 ESSENCE Festival Of Culture
  • Celebrity
    • ESSENCE 55
    • 2025 Black Music Month
    • 2024 Sexiest Men Of the Moment
    • Of The Essence
    • Celebrity News
    • If Not For My Girls
    • The State Of R&B
    • Time Of Essence
  • Fashion
    • 2024 ESSENCE FASHION HOUSE
    • SSENSE X ESSENCE
    • 2023 Best In Black Fashion Awards
    • Red Carpet
    • Fashion News
    • Accessories
  • Beauty
    • 2025 Best In Beauty Awards
    • Skin
    • Makeup
    • Nails
    • In The Chair
    • Couple-Care
    • Product Of The Week
    • Makeup Her Story
    • Hair
      • Hair News
      • Natural
      • Relaxed
      • Transitioning
      • Weave
      • 4C
  • Lifestyle
    • 2025 Travel Awards
    • Love
    • Parenting
    • Relationships
    • Bridal Bliss
    • Lifestyle News
    • Health & Wellness
    • ESSENCE Eats
    • Travel
    • Food & Drink
  • Entrepreneurship
    • 2024 Power 40
    • Money & Career
    • SOKO MRKT
  • News
    • State of the People 
    • 2025 Black Futures
    • Latest News
    • 2024 HBCU X ESSENCE
    • Paint The Polls Black
    • Culture
    • Politics
  • Shopping
    • 2024 Holiday Gift Guide
  • Video
  • Events
    • 2025 Hollywood House
    • 2025 Black Women In Hollywood
    • 2024 ESSENCE Fashion House
    • 2024 ESSENCE Film Festival
    • 2023 Wellness House
  • Subscribe
    • Magazine
    • Newsletter
Home • Op-Ed

Joe Manchin is Lone Democrat to Support Law Defunding Critical Race Theory. Except it Has Nothing to Do With Critical Race Theory.

Manchin joined Republican senators to pass Senator Tom Cotton's amendment to defund teaching so-called "Critical Race Theory." Except it's not actually Critical Race Theory.
Joe Manchin is Lone Democrat to Support Law Defunding Critical Race Theory. Except it's Unrelated to Critical Race Theory.
Photo by Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images
By Malaika Jabali · Updated August 13, 2021
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready…

It’s hard to say where to start with the following news. Whether it’s that Joe Manchin was the only Democrat to support an anti- “Critical Race Theory” amendment introduced by GOP Senator Tom Cotton (R-Arkansas), who’s had a personal vendetta for over a year with those who even mention American racism. Or the fact that the bill has nothing to do with Critical Race Theory but is being described as such by clueless Republicans. Or that this bill actually passed the Senate.

Let’s just start from the top.

Joe Manchin is continuing to operate as an actual Republican, this time joining 49 Republican senators Wednesday to pass an amendment that defunds “Critical Race Theory.”

The amendment would prohibit or limit “federal funding from being used to promote critical race theory or compel teachers or students to affirm critical race theory in prekindergarten programs, elementary schools, and secondary schools.”

The problem with this, as some may have heard by now, is that Critical Race Theory is an advanced field of scholarship that’s rarely taught outside of graduate school. It’s a relatively niche field that started among lawyers in the 1970s. If it’s taught at all in graduate school, it’s most often in law schools (that’s where I was first educated in it) and some graduate schools in other fields, like education. And even most law school students would say they never came across CRT in their years of legal training.

Critical race theory is an advanced course of scholarship that began to examine why legal decisions– like Brown v. Board of Education– did not actually result in substantive racial progress. It challenged the notion that the law was color blind and theorized that the law could, and did in fact, maintain racial hierarchies and white power structures. Experts in the field– like Kimberle Williams Crenshaw, Patricia Williams, and Kendall Thomas– found inspiration through the work of Harvard law professor Derrick Bell, whose teachings were foundational to the development of CRT.

Article continues after video.

Rather than teaching about individual lay-people’s roles in advancing racism, CRT is specifically focused on institutions and how those in power use the law and other means to maintain racial hierarchies. It doesn’t teach people to be racially divided; it shows how systemic decisions and practices throughout America’s legal and social institutions continue to do that work all on their own. CRT scholars also examine how to curb this systemic racism.

But you wouldn’t know this from the flurry of PTA meetings throughout the country, with white parents lamenting the hostile takeover of “critical race theory,” frantic that their 10-year-old sons and daughters are being taught white guilt.

There are multiple facets to CRT that cannot be whittled down to “teaching about American racism,” but you can be assured it’s not a field of scholarship taught in anything below college-level courses. It’s like thinking kindergarteners are learning calculus. While kids can and should learn the building blocks of math, to call addition and subtraction calculus simply because they involve numbers is deceptive. But that’s precisely what the rightwing fury is about. It’s not meant to be accurate; it’s meant to stir the fury of their base.

Indeed some children may be learning about racism in school. But simply learning about racism isn’t CRT. Some students may be learning about Jim Crow or white supremacy. But this is just called history. CRT is a distinct body of work, and if legislators just want to ban history that makes America appear less than stellar, they should just say that.

And in the meantime, they should also avoid using the term “cancel culture” to describe being censored ever again, because these right wing legislators are using their actual power and resources to systemically block learning for millions of students. If anything, this simply adds another lesson to the curriculum for CRT scholars to show why their field of study was created in the first place.

TOPICS:  Critical Race Theory

Read More

Health Matters: Here's What You Need To Know About Fibroids
Lifestyle
Health Matters: Here's What You Need To Know About Fibroids
Bridal Bliss: Noni And DeChaun Said 'I Do' With Celebrations In St. Lucia And Atlanta
Weddings
Bridal Bliss: Noni And DeChaun Said 'I Do' With Celebrations...
WATCH: Bridal Bliss: Noni and DeChaun Went From Island Vows To An Atlanta Celebration
Videos
WATCH: Bridal Bliss: Noni and DeChaun Went From Island Vows ...
Kamala Harris Says She Will Not Run For Governor Of California In 2026
News
Kamala Harris Says She Will Not Run For Governor Of Californ...
The Capri Comeback I Didn't See Coming
Shop
The Capri Comeback I Didn't See Coming
COMPANY INFORMATION
  • Our Company
  • Customer Service
  • Essence Ventures
  • Change Your Address
  • Contact Us
  • Job Opportunities
  • Internships
  • Media Kit
  • tag
SUBSCRIBE
  • Newsletters
  • Give a Gift of ESSENCE
  • Print & Digital App
FOLLOW US
MORE ON ESSENCE
  • Home
  • Love
  • Celebrity
  • Beauty
  • Hair
  • Fashion
  • ESSENCE Festival of Culture

ESSENCE.com is part of ESSENCE Communications, Inc.

Essence may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.

©2024 ESSENCE Communications Inc. All Rights Reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Essence.com Advertising Terms | Accessibility Statement

Get The ESSENCE Newsletter and
Special Offers delivered to your inbox

By clicking Sign Up, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Get The ESSENCE Magazine
by subscribing below
subscribe now
  • 2025 ESSENCE Festival Of Culture
  • Celebrity
    • ESSENCE 55
    • 2025 Black Music Month
    • 2024 Sexiest Men Of the Moment
    • Of The Essence
    • Celebrity News
    • If Not For My Girls
    • The State Of R&B
    • Time Of Essence
  • Fashion
    • 2024 ESSENCE FASHION HOUSE
    • SSENSE X ESSENCE
    • 2023 Best In Black Fashion Awards
    • Red Carpet
    • Fashion News
    • Accessories
  • Beauty
    • 2025 Best In Beauty Awards
    • Skin
    • Makeup
    • Nails
    • In The Chair
    • Couple-Care
    • Product Of The Week
    • Makeup Her Story
    • Hair
  • Lifestyle
    • 2025 Travel Awards
    • Love
    • Parenting
    • Relationships
    • Bridal Bliss
    • Lifestyle News
    • Health & Wellness
    • ESSENCE Eats
    • Travel
    • Food & Drink
  • Entrepreneurship
    • 2024 Power 40
    • Money & Career
    • SOKO MRKT
  • News
    • State of the People 
    • 2025 Black Futures
    • Latest News
    • 2024 HBCU X ESSENCE
    • Paint The Polls Black
    • Culture
    • Politics
  • Shopping
    • 2024 Holiday Gift Guide
  • Video
  • Events
    • 2025 Hollywood House
    • 2025 Black Women In Hollywood
    • 2024 ESSENCE Fashion House
    • 2024 ESSENCE Film Festival
    • 2023 Wellness House
  • Subscribe
    • Magazine
    • Newsletter
  • Entertainment
    • Of The Essence
    • Celebrity News
    • If not for my Girls
    • The State of R&B
  • Black Women In
    • Girls United Beautiful Possibilities
    • 2025 Best in Beauty Awards
    • Skin
    • Makeup
    • Nails
    • Hair
  • Style
    • Love
    • Parenting
    • Relationships
    • Bridal Bliss
    • Lifestyle News
    • Health and Wellness
    • Travel
    • Food and Drink
  • Culture
    • 2023 BEST IN BLACK FASHION AWARDS
    • 2024 ESSENCE FASHION HOUSE
    • Red Carpet
    • Fashion News
    • Accessories
  • Business
    • Power 40
  • Festival
    • Latest News
    • Paint the Polls Black
    • Culture
    • Politics
  • Sign In
  • Subscribe
    • MAGAZINE
    • NEWSLETTER
  • Search
  • Login
  • Subscribe
    • Magazine
    • Newsletter
  • Search

WHERE BLACK CULTURE, COMMUNITY AND CONSCIOUSNESS MEET

Sign up for ESSENCE Newsletters to see more of Black Women’s Boundlessness

Your email is required.
Your email is in invalid format.
Confirm email is required.
Email did not match.
Select the newsletters you'd like to receive:
Please select at least one option.
Essence

Thank you for subscribing. Unlock VIP access! Join our SMS list for exclusive offers you won’t find anywhere else.

Your phone number is required
Please enter a new one and try again.
Invalid phone number
Please enter a new one and try again.